April 29th, 2010
|03:16 pm - Musing on Arizona and Bigotry|
The vile immigration law recently passed in Arizona doesn't particularly surprise me, because I visited Arizona in the early 90s with my friend Aaron, and this law reminds me of my visit to Tucson. I was in Arizona for a few days and visited by Arizona and Tucson. My primary memory of Phoenix is of the ugliest city that I've ever seen, which seemed to largely consist of freeways, used car lots and pest control agencies. Given that I was living in LA at the time (which is exceptionally ugly during the day, and deceptively lovely at night), the fact that I found Phoenix ugly is particularly striking.
However, what I most remember about visiting Arizona was a day I spent in Tucson. It was clear that there was something seriously wrong with that city when we drove in – we can in through the hispanic & native american slum. It was quite literally that – multiple square miles of run down depressing poverty where everyone seemed to be either hispanic or native american. Then, there was the downtown – a large, well off, and generally pleasant and artsy city, where the vast majority of people were white, with a small number of asian and black people. There were a few hispanic or native american service workers evident, but not many. The downtown seemed far more functional than many US downtowns, with an abundance of high-end galleries (many of which featured native american art and native american designs being sold by white people) and a wide variety of nice-looking restaurants.
However, the single most striking thing I saw in Tucson was the downtown bus mall. Like Portland, and many other cities, Tucson has (or at least in the early 90s had) a central area where all of the city buses converged. It was an area several blocks long with what looked like several stops for every bus route in the city. It was a utilitarian but not ugly area with abundant shade and metal benches. However, what struck me was the people. At one end of this multiple block strip were a group of people waiting for the bus who were predominantly white, but with a moderate number of black and asian people. People were talking and interacting with one another to a degree common in fairly functional cities. Then, literally more than a block away was another group of people – all of whom appeared to be hispanic or native american, who were also interacting with one another. There was literally no one in between these two groups. At the time, I was considerably less aware of racial issues than I am now, but I still remember those two groups of people who did not interact or even glance at one another. I was vividly reminded of images I had seen of the pre-desegregation South. The bus mall in Tucson is my most vivid memory of Arizona and also why their recent immigration law did not surprise me.
Current Mood: thoughtful
|Date:||May 2nd, 2010 09:05 pm (UTC)|| |
|(Link)|...it looks to me to be a deeply racist state that's in the process of getting even worse.
Arizona's population is more diverse and less segregated than Oregon's.
i mean, for serious, you guys are 93% white there. we're 25% mexican-american in Arizona, and that number is on the increase.
isn't oregon the most racist state in the union or something?
isn't portland less integrated than tucson
if you look at the facts and figures?
isn't it real easy for you to sit back and ignore problems in your own backyard while tut-tutting at tucson arizona based on your very privileged white observation of people of color 18 years ago?
maybe just maybe a discussion of arizona's racial politics needs to start with facts and not self-righteous white out-of-staters declaring that the state is "deeply racist" and "getting worse." educate yourself first!
FWIW, the 2009 state figures have Oregon being 90% white.
More to the point, there isn't a massively racist immigration law or equally racist and appalling laws surrounding education
. Oregon has a deeply racist past, but the laws and practices have changed. I'm not denying that Oregon (like every other state in the US) has serious problems with racism. However, claiming that Oregon is as or more racist than a state that has just passed several utterly vile laws. You can be in denial about the fact that you live in one of the most racist states in the US, but the facts remain - Arizona is a state firmly in the grip of the Republican party, which is the party of racism. It's a center for Tea Party activity, and it's a state that recently passed some of the most racist legislation in the US. Oregon is none of these things.
|Date:||May 2nd, 2010 09:56 pm (UTC)|| |
this is the same self-righteous argument that says that the south is more racist than the north, while ignoring the fact that the reason there aren't as many people of color in the north is because of ignorance of racist sundown-town laws that are in their "deeply racist past."
meanwhile, 10 hate groups in Oregon, 15 in Arizona
according to splc. 4 hate groups centered in portland, 1 hate group centered in tucson.
oregon's got 3.8 million people, arizona's got 6.5. looks to me like you've got more hate groups per capita also.
So, the fact that most people in your state consistently vote for openly bigoted candidates who pass openly bigoted laws has absolutely no bearing on how racist the populace (as a whole) or the government of Arizona are - interesting logic there.
Edit: Oregon has an exceptionally racist past - Arizona has an exceptionally racist present day - in Oregon things have been improving wrt race for at least the past 15 years, in Arizona racial problems are clearly getting worse, and of late they've been clear getting worse at a rapid rate.
Edited at 2010-05-02 10:13 pm (UTC)
|Date:||May 2nd, 2010 10:33 pm (UTC)|| |
didn't say that.
i did, however, note that my city doesn't vote for the openly bigoted candidates and oppose the openly bigoted laws.
but hey don't let that stop you from drawing conclusions from a bus station visit you took 18 years ago, and saw with racist white eyeballs.
So, the large & obviously segregated slum I saw was clearly an optical illusion - I suppose there are points of view where that idea makes sense.